Everton banter 3

09 Oct 2025 19:24:49
No this is a statement of the bleeding obvious, but fact is, why is Henderson in the England squad and Garner is sat on his ass.
Answers on a post card to FA headquarters.

{Ed025's Note - because Tuchel is a prick AB, a self centred egotist who doesn,t know his arse from his elbow imo mate..

09 Oct 2025 20:07:30
That’s a pretty complete answer ED. No disputing it mate.

09 Oct 2025 20:31:10
Would rather fat sam than that tool.

10 Oct 2025 06:31:30
The bigger insult is Wharton not being in it.

08 Oct 2025 20:08:09
Really liked this JP article on the BBC site, balanced and credit / recognition well deserved. He's been outstanding for us and for England for a long time now and, for me, the undisputed No.1 Keeper!

09 Oct 2025 19:52:42
There’s been many a debate on where Pickford ranks in Everton’s goal keeping greats. I had him in 6th but now feel he’s in the top 5. The guy might not be our greatest keeper to stand in goal but he his performances have kept in the league in recent years and without him, who knows which division we would be in.

He’s no Southall; he’s no West; he’s no Howard… but he’s one of ours and will deserve his spot in the hall of fame when it comes.

09 Oct 2025 20:09:04
Well he went a long way to helping us beat Palace at the weekend.

09 Oct 2025 20:32:19
Never been in a debate yet BR.

09 Oct 2025 20:34:32
Howard better than Pickford? Not a chance. That's like saying Beto is better than Lukaku. Weird comment that.

09 Oct 2025 21:06:53
As good for us as Howard was, he's nowhere near the level that JP has consistently shown over the last few seasons.

09 Oct 2025 21:19:52
Howard was a solid player Big Reg who marshalled the area better than Pickford does. I think Pickford is up there since he’s calmed down and ironed out some of his errors. There were several seasons where you thought Pickford would cost us the game but he has matured a lot. Howard was the opposite: always trusted him to keep a clean sheet but his last few seasons he became more error prone.

I’d still have West and Southall ahead of him but I’d now place Pickford above Martyn and Segar. I can’t decide between Howard and him as to who is third.

10 Oct 2025 06:32:42
Howard used to concede every shot from over 20 yards out, was awful 1v1, not a great penalty saver, worse with his feet than Pickford.

Mind boggling and I assume it’s nostalgia to say Howard was better than Pickford. Howard is closer to Ramsdale than he is to Pickford.

10 Oct 2025 06:40:08
Going further gack, I would also argue different eras' regarding West and Southall.

11 Oct 2025 09:42:20
Pickford is twice the GK Howard was.
Big Nev is one of the best I’ve ever seen do it.

08 Oct 2025 12:29:05
Tarks just signed a 2 year contract extension according to ssn.

08 Oct 2025 07:39:03
{Ed's Note - 007 has posted a new article entitled, Was Heitinga / Slot The Secret?

07 Oct 2025 12:09:04
Afternoon pal all this playing league matches outside of your country the league is situated is going to be the new normal in the new decade I reckon but god I hope I am wrong I don't care to watch Everton playing a league match anywhere except in the British isles sorry not for me we have the European competitions if we want that but I guess greed will be the order of the day and eventually premier league clubs will follow their continental counterparts from Spain Germany Italy etc.

08 Oct 2025 00:17:18
I agree, think is strange as one team will lose home advantage. But as you say if the money is good the clubs may well do it.

08 Oct 2025 07:57:07
Been getting an awful lot of enjoyment watching non-league football when Everton are away. Once Superleague comes (it will) the Prem and rules will change and for the better.

08 Oct 2025 12:46:22
Unfortunately it’s inevitable that football will go the same way as a lot of American sports in that they’ll play some matches in other countries - this will be to increase the brand and generate extra income.

The big issue is it’s the season ticket holders that will miss out.

If you’ve paid for a season ticket then you should be entitled to watch every home game - if that is then in another country what are you supposed to do? The club isn’t going to take fans with them at their expense. Not many fans will travel to another country at great expense to watch a game they’ve already paid to watch.

Unless when purchasing a season ticket it explicitly says you won’t be able to watch all home matches due to some being played abroad then surely there’s a breach of contract by the club in changing rules - therefore it’ll be a breach of contract and imagine there’ll be potentially a case to answer legally.

Whether anyone challenges that either individually or as a class action will remain to be seen as imagine clubs will then decide to not renew season tickets for anyone challenging them.

It’s all about money these days and not the fans - if clubs want to play abroad it’s unlikely that fans will be able to stop it as it’s the clubs that have all the power.

Sad state of affairs.

{Ed001's Note - they were looking at adding a 39th game a season when they investigated this possibility a few years ago.}

08 Oct 2025 15:41:08
Aaaahhh yes I remember the 39th game option.

08 Oct 2025 17:00:49
In Italy the teams are given money based on their popularity, viewing figures on top of the standard starting amounts and placements. In Spain the top clubs get the lions share after the standard payouts. They get money even based on how players are put up for interviews.

The EPL does a better job for the league rather than individuals. The brand is much stronger as well due to the popularity of all the clubs and the promotional work in the UK is massive.

It was said by one of the top guys in the negotiations of the international deal that selling the EPL is the easiest due to it being a soap opera. Every club has a back story, every team has a history with the other. It's not the same in other countries.

This may prolongue the lack of need to look into a game abroad. I see it being more like the preseason Prem league we were involved in. That way they get more games, more teams and the small sampled thril of a mini 4 team league.

09 Oct 2025 20:05:21
Hope so BJU. Concept of a 39th game is ridiculous.

Keep the league format. Sort out the breakaway six monopoly. Keep the league competitive and get rid of the transfer window that has driven up prices.

09 Oct 2025 20:18:00
I know this won't happen but why not have a tournament to see who's got the best league.
Im not sure how many a squad is classed at these days. Let's say its 25. You have to have at least 1 player from each club in your league and they all have to play at some point in the tournament unless they are injured.

{Ed025's Note - for me MN it would just be another money maker for UEFA mate, they play too much as it is for me especially the players who play in European games, Internationals, cup games, stupid bloody friendlies and things like AFCON, the Euro,s and the world cup, its just overkill..

07 Oct 2025 12:03:34
Well fellow evertonians B&B Beto and Barry have the grand total of one league goal combined between them how many more do you think they will score this season league only and you can't say none as unless you exclude the goal already scored I personally can't see them getting five between them which means four more goals for the entire season ??????.

07 Oct 2025 15:44:35
We have B&B when what we really need is a five star hotel.

{Ed025's Note - love it BMD..

07 Oct 2025 19:58:02
More like bodger and badger them 2.

08 Oct 2025 12:11:31
Blankety blank if where doing this.

06 Oct 2025 20:26:29
Apparently we are being linked with Joshua Zirkzeewhat do people think I don't really have much of an option we need a goal scorer not sure if this one would be an upgrade probably is better than what we have got but we should be moving heaven and earth to unearth a gem.

{Ed025's Note - what i have seen of Zirkzee TB he is not enough of an upgrade to be viable mate..

06 Oct 2025 22:28:15
He’s actually a downgrade on what we have.

{Ed025's Note - Mr Bean would not be a downgrade on what we have Swan..

07 Oct 2025 03:39:04
Mr Bean is better at football than Zirkzee.

He averages a goal every 11 games, has no athletic ability, cannot hold the ball, doesn’t make good runs.

Say what you will about Beto and Barry, but they at least try, they don’t succeed, but they try.

Zirkzee has the work rate of a sloth on sleeping pills.

07 Oct 2025 12:48:26
If we got the Zirkzee that was at Bologna, then I would take him. Linked play incredibly well for them and bought the likes of Ndoye, Orsolini and Saelemaekers into the game, which could bode well for Grealish, KDH, Charlie and Nidaye.

07 Oct 2025 13:16:57
That being said, there are plenty of forwards I would rather us target.

Missed the boat on Emegha and Bonny, who seems to have hit the ground running for Inter. Lad stinks of Lukaku. Funnily enough, another that was a lot cheaper than Barry.

Nikola Krstovic from Atlanta would be my pick. Out and out finisher - right foot, left foot or head and a good age with enough experience under his belt. Castellanos from Lazio would be a decent signing also.

07 Oct 2025 14:47:16
Red a article before that we could be in for jesus from arsenal in January anyone else heard anything about tha.

{Ed025's Note - god i hope not Shakey..

07 Oct 2025 19:34:35
Who is this DJU lad anyone? Apparently he is up for a January transfer £17.5 million never heard of him but I only really watch British football.

08 Oct 2025 07:07:40
Jesus, I heard we would leave him where he is till April 5th.

08 Oct 2025 17:09:34
21 year old striker Ron, who I think we should have gone for in the summer. Has bags of ability and looks a decent finisher. I think what is most impressive about him is his ability to assess things around him and not be selfish when there is a teammate in a better position than him.

I think we may have missed the boat on this one and he may go to a bigger team.

09 Oct 2025 08:52:39
So another young forward? Do you think he would be ready to start straight away then Or another youngster with potential? I don't bother YouTubeing players because clips can make anyone look a worldy. and like i say i don't really watch foreign football BN. seems like a decent price though if he is as good as you say i seen 9 goals in 10 and 3 assists.

09 Oct 2025 10:20:29
He is indeed mate. I think he is comfortably a better footballer than both Barry and Beto, so I would assume so. He can also play in different setups so allows for a bit more flexibility.

Yes, I get that Ron, that makes complete sense. However, he has played in Europe for 20 odd games and has about a 1 in 2 goal rate. Not too bad for a 21 year old.

I think just off the eye test alone and watching him with a football at his feet, you can see he is a better player than the two we have but who knows mate.

Wouldn't be suprised if he went back to Benfica tbh and then we went and got him for 60m in a year knowing us!

09 Oct 2025 12:27:40
That's sounds like us BN???.

06 Oct 2025 15:06:44
Looks like we have gotten even with the Gers for selling us one of the worst signings we have ever made, even if we are still 6 million out of pocket.

06 Oct 2025 15:17:06
Hopefully Thelwell comes and picks up Mykolenko for that £6m ?.

06 Oct 2025 16:52:24
Think you may be a huge outlier there Swan but I can certainly keep you company.

06 Oct 2025 14:21:43
What are everyone's thoughts on our new owners so far?

06 Oct 2025 15:19:04
Can’t have many complaints. They aren’t constantly in the spotlight, they seem to stay out of the on the pitch stuff, which is a fantastic relief after the last maniac.

Need a few more seasons, they’ve given us money to spend so I assume they’ve done their due diligence with our financial situation, they are known for fixing clubs like us.

I much prefer them to Moshiri or the unambiguous oafs we had before.

06 Oct 2025 15:31:08
They've done what I'd want them to do. Cleared the debt and got the club moving forward.

The biggest change is how many people we now have in top places on the board and running each department of the club. We look like a big global business instead of an aging sleeping giant.

06 Oct 2025 15:55:48
Think they have been spot on so far.

06 Oct 2025 17:22:35
Can't complain so far. Its refreshing not hearing much about 'the state' of our club. Its good to see real progress on and off the pitch
Keep it going.

06 Oct 2025 17:49:55
They know how to run a business rather than "grew up in the boys pen" crap. They have put in place an experienced professional management group and from what I can see left them to do a job rather than constantly interfering like the last bunch. The jury is still out and the goal over the next few years has to be European football and hopefully a trophy, a good start but still work to do.

06 Oct 2025 18:29:32
Certainly got the the right manager.

06 Oct 2025 23:11:06
Only thing missing was a proper centre forward in my eyes.

Shipped out some of the deadwood (Harrison, Doucs, etc) . Brought in upgrades replacements (Grealish, KDH) . Delivered on the new stadium and sorted out finances out so we aren’t liable to another PSR issue.

Phase one: ‘steady the ship’ seems complete. It’s what happens next that will tell us how good they are as owners. We’ve bought a few players for the future, the team doesn’t look as if they will be scrapping at the bottom of the table and they are investing in the women’s game. I hope the next phase goes as well as the first! The signs are promising.

07 Oct 2025 11:23:17
New owners cannot be blamed for some poor recruiting decisions, they have appointed people to do that roll, then allowed them to get on with it.
Yes, the lack of a new right back is a concern, and a proven goal scorer, but that is far from their fault, they have provided the funds, but have left football people to make the decisions, and with our resent history of owner making such decisions, it is the right approach.

07 Oct 2025 12:42:10
First season first transfer window how can we complain, yes we need further improvements but we new it wouldn't be done in 1 window, think a right back was the only thing I'd of said we new we needed one and never got one which still baffles me now, but roll in xmas window hopefully they can address what has so fair been a good start to the season .

{Ed025's Note - yeah Pasty a RB should have been one of our top recruitment goals along with a striker for me, but as you say we have done a lot of good things and we all knew it would take more than just 1 window mate, i know hindsight is a wonderful thing but does anyone else think we may have let Ashley Young go a season too early?, he is still as fit as a butchers and i thought done really well for us last season, not everyone,s cup of tea but while Jarrad is out i would have liked to see us play 3 centre halves with Myko and Ash as fullbacks but with cover from the big lads....but maybe thats just me..

06 Oct 2025 11:03:49
The difference having a midfielder who runs at teams with the ball is so refreshing. Alcaraz made all the difference on Sunday, the lads first thought was to move the ball forward. And that encouraged other players to do the same.
At home we need to be a lot more positive, start as a 4-3-3 with KDH, Alcaraz and Gana/ Garner.

06 Oct 2025 17:24:31
Garner should be our rb, love him in midfield but it's an area of strength. Rb isn't unfortunately and Garner would improve that.

{Ed025's Note - i think hes great in midfield for us BB and he creates chances that if we had decent forwards would result in goals, wasted at full back for me mate..

06 Oct 2025 09:03:29
Great comeback victory yesterday and sitting pretty in 8th.
Armstrong getting MoM for Preston is great as well. Let's hope the good news keeps on coming.

I do think we should play Garner at rb now, his distribution and control from there could be a real bonus. We have options in Dewsbury-hall, Tim, Rohl, Alcaraz and Grealish who can easily play the 8 role next to Gana.

Thought Alcaraz was excellent when he came on.

06 Oct 2025 10:27:05
Dropping KDH back to 8 and playing Alcaraz at 10 could be the move Bunks, no Grealish in the next game of course so that may hamper that plan.

08 Oct 2025 07:11:29
Think Ndaye will play left eide in that game.