Everton Discussion posts 3

22 Nov 2025 12:22:55
Ward Prowse at 31 would that be a good signing?

{Ed025's Note - no..

22 Nov 2025 17:15:43
Loan for 6 months maybe but not for Jimmy G or as permanent.

23 Nov 2025 13:55:34
Well he's not getting game time in a struggling West ham team. He'd only good for free kicks and not to the level Garner is getting to. Plus Garner takes a decent free kick himself.

23 Nov 2025 17:12:30
So that’s a no then.

20 Nov 2025 12:17:52
Well just been reading the three biggest divers in the Premiership are Salah, Fernandez and guess who; Grealish hmmm.

20 Nov 2025 17:00:14
All very good at drawing a foul.

21 Nov 2025 10:04:12
Biggest divers? Or most fouls won? Grealish gets kicked to bits because he controls the ball so well, should win more fouls if anything.

21 Nov 2025 18:59:26
Again who is making these statements? Grealish is one of the most fouled, how that is translated into being a "diver" is anyones guess. You will have to stop reading this rubbish Guernsey mate, at our age it will make you go mad or blind or worse case both.

21 Nov 2025 20:31:37
Almost every game he has two players on him as soon as he gets the ball mate agree he’s kicked for the whole 90 plus minutes.

23 Nov 2025 13:58:03
Grealish gets fouled because he keeps the ball virtually under his body. Other players get ball from under their feet whereas grealish kerosene it close. Opposition usually have no choice but to make contact with him if they want the ball. Clever play in all honesty.

12 Nov 2025 12:35:46
Can't believe they're still going on about that VD disallowed goal. Sky milking this to death.

13 Nov 2025 08:06:00
Big Club syndrome mate.

19 Nov 2025 02:49:46
It's ridiculous, bmd, you'd think Liverpool were the only team to have a goal disallowed in the history of football the way this has played out. I'm sure we had something similar against spurs a few weeks before, didn't see all the crying for weeks from us. Embarrassing really.

04 Nov 2025 13:29:51
I don't think Barry and Beto are playing very well at the moment. Anyone agree?

04 Nov 2025 15:47:06
Think you are right there mate.

06 Nov 2025 16:18:31
I think even a blind man would have noticed that Big Reg. The only problem we seem to have is that Moyes and his staff have gone brian dead i. e. Cannot see what everyone else can.

04 Nov 2025 12:32:03
Just been listening to the radio re Rachel Reed and the state of the country, the definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting good results, it never happens hope our powers that be at Everton are listening hmmmmmm.

05 Nov 2025 18:43:58
Maybe we need to Reform our tactics, and not be so Conservative. Might help us stop Labouring in games.

06 Nov 2025 18:52:55
Good one BB.

03 Nov 2025 21:48:56
Some on here will be glad you hear that I'm not bothering watching or going the game while Moyes is at the helm I just can't bring myself to do it, I hate this manager we have, I'm staying away until he has gone.

04 Nov 2025 09:42:37
Hate really!

04 Nov 2025 12:36:32
I can think of stronger words but it is before the watershed.

06 Nov 2025 18:53:32
See you Saturday mate.

02 Nov 2025 14:01:49
If Rohl doesn't start tomorrow, Moyes is a pleb.

02 Nov 2025 16:07:11
Think he will mate, a good player who will be invaluable to us this season.

02 Nov 2025 18:24:56
Fingers crossed GB. He offers something very different to anybody else in our side. He has to play if fit imo mate.

03 Nov 2025 11:00:44
Moyes will start with Gana and Garner because Rohl isn’t Premiership ready apparently.

04 Nov 2025 02:26:55
Bloody hell I can see in to the future. Or is it Moyes is just so predictable?

27 Oct 2025 02:40:03
We went from Leighton Baines, to Lucas Digne, a downgrade but certainly not a bad player, he was amazing for us and that fat fraud who ruined Mourinho's Inter and Real teams, binned him off.

To then end up with Vitaly Mykolenko.

Actually impressive to go that far down the ladder, I cannot believe some of our fans think he's been a solid signing. He's had 4 good games I can think of, he's truly dreadful, zero ability going forward, can be okay defensively, no athletic talent.

He's like Tony Hibbert if you halved his defensive ability and removed his good crossing.

Is there a worse left back in the league? I don't think so honestly. Maybe Zinchenko? Even the ones that aren't great like Sessegnon and Dorgu, are at least quick, so they can at least carry the ball forward or get back if they are out of position.

A truly tremendously bad signing.

27 Oct 2025 21:11:29
But seems our best LB Swan. I've read that our new LB is looking for a loan in january back to Spain. Unfortunately we never seem to have a manager who will make changes and give them time to implement themselves. Just hope as per usual with a Moyes team, especially in 1st spell as Everton manager, that we crack on after the new year.

But the constant chop and change of our 2 poor strikers is really frustrating. For me keeping Travers in summer didn't make any sense for the King signing. Waste of wages to have 4x 1st team squad Goalkeepers.

28 Oct 2025 09:11:35
Mycolenkos problems are his ability, Brain and confidence.

27 Oct 2025 00:00:07
How did we get bullied on every set piece today with the size of the lads in our team?

Why was O'Brien on the post when he is the biggest player on the pitch?

If we know Pickfords weak spot is commanding his area, why have our coaches and players not cottoned on to that, let alone after 4 or 5 corners/ throw ins. Just get O'Brien or Tarkowski to stand in front of him and the man to stop him getting bullied.

Even a Sunday league team would have the nous to spot this.

Mykolenko is an absolutely shocking footballer. He isn't even good at the defensive aspect of the game.

Tarkowski is one of the most overrated Everton players I have seen. Just because he throws his body in front of shots he gets lauded as some colossus defender. He is slow in body and mind. He ball watches all the time and thinks its funny and is laughing when Richarlison does him and nearly scores a 1 on 1 with Pickford when we are 2 down. Fella is a helmet.

James Garner is fantastic and can play anywhere.

Would love to see Rohl get a start. Head an shoulders above what we have in the middle.

KDH isn't as good as people think.

Ndiaye quality again but teams know to double up on him and can do without stress because we don't have a fullback that offers an option.

Grealish quality player but very predictable.

26 Oct 2025 09:16:42
Really good piece of Everton strikers since Lukaku on bbc webpage. Interesting the best goals per minute rate is Omar Niasse, shows how bad we have been in that aspect.

Player

Fee

Games/ goals

Minutes per goal

Thierno Barry (2025)

£27.5m

8/ 0

-

Armando Broja (2024)

Loan

10/ 0

-

Beto (2023)

£21.5m

68/ 12

247

Youssef Chermiti (2023)

£12m

22/ 0

-

Neal Maupay (2022)

£12m

29/ 1

1227

Salomon Rondon (2021)

Free

27/ 1

887

Joshua King (2021)

£2m

11/ 0

-

Moise Kean (2019)

£25m

32/ 2

425

Richarlison (2018)

£35m

135/ 43

259

Cenk Tosun (2018)

£27m

50/ 9

265

Wayne Rooney (2017)

Free

31/ 10

228

Sandro Ramirez (2017)

£5.3m

8/ 0

-

Enner Valencia (2016)

Loan

21/ 3

236

Dominic Calvert-Lewin (2016)

£1.5m

239/ 57

276

Oumar Niasse (2016)

£13.5m

35/ 8

163

Shani Tarashaj (2016)

£3.5m

0/ 0

-

Leandro Rodriguez (2015)

£0.5m

0/ 0

-.

26 Oct 2025 19:18:28
So Niasse was our best striker since Lukaku?

26 Oct 2025 23:46:31
Where's Eto'o.

19 Oct 2025 19:16:56
3 managers reject Rangers because they don't want to. work with Kevin Thelwell. On them was the days!

23 Oct 2025 20:41:06
I don't think its thelwell so much. More to the fact that Rangers are atrocious this season. They aren't a nailed on bet on Ladbrokes for me anymore lol.