25 Aug 2014 16:46:38
Hi there,

I've come over from the United page to hear some of your views on Welbeck.

At United, we rate him very highly, the only thing lacking from his game is composure, the chances he gets where he doesn't get time to think he buries them it's just the ones where he has to think which he at times blunders.

Most don't want him to leave and I'm very surprised to see a fair amount of your fans saying you wouldn't want him.

He's a typical Everton player imo. Hard working, young, british, nearing the finished article, etc.

I think that IF he ends up with you he'll be a bigger hit than Lukaku (just my opinion).

It'll be very interesting to hear what happens but as I said United fans (mostly) want him to stay because as soon as he nails that composure in his game he's going to be a terrific forward.

if we had Welbeck fit for the opening 2 games I think we genuinely would have won both, his ability to pull and stretch defenders is remarkable, something that United were lacking last season and are lacking currently (until Di Maria signs).

Do any of you want Welbeck?

Ed, (opinions) do you think Welbeck will Leave Manchester United this summer and do you see him at Everton or elsewhere?

{Ed025's Note - i personally dont see him leaving jose, RVP seems to play when he feels like it, so it will leave you short up front, he has got some good aspects to his game but as you say finishing is not one of them, so would i want him?..yes..would he be my first choice..no..

1.) 25 Aug 2014
ED025,

Last year RVP was a disgrace, ran away with his tail between his legs when it started getting tough.

This year, even though he's good friends with LVG I can't see him getting away with anything like that.

that said though, it looks as if Welbeck and Hernandez are off, I think Di Maria will play up top like Robben did for Holland and James Wilson will come in as the 4th striker (who is shaping up brilliantly).

although it might leave us short in EPL experience I don't think we'll be in that bad of a position.

Welbeck's only poor part of his game is his finishing, which admittedly is a major part of a forwards job role.

would you agree that if he nails that composure he would one of the best british forwards, only behind Rooney imo. his game is so much more rounded than Sturridge's (apart from the finishing).

Also, I'm a bit concerned as to WHY he's leaving.

Welbeck can play out wide if we go 4-3-3, up top and at a push could probably cover wing back. He's a very versatile player.

I think United will regret letting him go though.

{Ed025's Note - i agree with your assessment of RVP jose, but to be honest cant see danny becoming a great forward mate..

2.) 25 Aug 2014
25 Aug 2014 17:19:54
I can pull and stretch defenders too, should of seen me photobomb johan hammars selfie by pulling his ears 3 years ago

3.) 25 Aug 2014
25 Aug 2014 17:21:15
Personally I think that welbeck would be a good addition for us but, depending on the asking price I would be skeptical. He is really quick and would definitely be an option off of the bench or as an alternative if Lukaku gets injured. For me he would be better than Eto'o (with his ridiculous wage demands) but whether or not he would be the type of player we need, I'm unsure.

{Ed025's Note - exactly my feelings bloo..

4.) 25 Aug 2014
The talk at the minute is of a loan deal which could work out great you.

for me, Welbeck needs a club like Everton and I think he's perfect for the club, I don't mean in terms of stature I mean in terms of the way you build players.

ED025, I can't see him becoming a great forward but he's more than capable of being a 20 goal a season man.

I think he'd be a great fit at Everton, tactically he seems easy to adjust, his work rate is incredible and IF you were to sign him be it permanent or loan I think you would see the best of him.

I hope you get him on loan to be honest, you'll help improve his game big time and I think he could be the difference between 7th and 5th for your lot.

5.) 26 Aug 2014
Jeez how desperate are you to get rid of him? Welbeck equals Bambi on ice. Try advertising him on someone else's site.

6.) 26 Aug 2014
He is a good forward, not a great one. Certainly not as good as Sturridge.This is the level of player we can attract. let's not kid ourselves.

7.) 26 Aug 2014
Daveyboy,

I love Welbeck, but he's not going to stay at United. Funnily enough I quite like Everton, the way they're run, etc.

He'll go on to have a better career than Lukaku who is just as bad as Balotelli.

Try finding out why Chelsea wanted rid of him so badly.

Smeggs,

he has the potential to be as good as Andy Cole imo.

the only part of his game lacking in comparison to Sturridge is the finishing, he's an all around better player bar that one problem.

he also steps up when it matters. Always superb for England (shut a lot of people up in the WC with how good he was). Not to mention in the UCL against Real Madrid, etc.

Top player who learns very well.

If he was called Danielo Welbechhio he would be of the most coveted young forward in the world.