Everton Banter Archive January 20 2015

 

Use our rumours form to send us everton transfer rumours.

20 Jan 2015 22:19:31
Don't tend to post straight after a game. Reaction can be knee jerk. Just spent ages reading all the posts from last night and today's.
Would just like to state what a passionate, knowledgeable, humorous and articulate set of existing and new posters are on this site. Far better analysis that reading the papers.
Never read other clubs sites but would me amazed if they compare and the posters care as much as we do about our club's heritage and it's future.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 20:33:08
It really is pointless regurgitating with varying slants the reasons behind our dismal performances, but I would like to offer a word of advice to Bill.
From personal experience the hardest thing to do is to dismiss an employee.
The realisation, in the real world, that you are taking away a persons livelihood and inflicting pain and uncertainty on the family concerned makes the decision heart rendering.
However, taking personalities out of the process, the decision always comes down to what is in the best interests of the company and the employees that remain.
Football, with the Murdoch money, is not the real world. Managers and players are paid outrageous salaries way out of line with highly qualified professions who have more responsibilities and pressures to deal with.
In this respect Bill you will not be inflicting any form of hardship on RM, certainly not financially, as a season in the premiership guarantees security for life.
However, you are guardian of a footballing heritage and with that comes a responsibility to a knowledgable fan base that spend part of their wages supporting our great club.
You too are an Evertonians through and through and like all supporters you deserve better than what is being served up by the present regime.
All supporters are aware we are not a club that readily takes to sacking managers after a period of poor results, but when the timescale of under performance puts the Premiership status of our great club in jeopardy action is not only necessary but urgently required.
Bill do what is needed to safeguard the positive future of our club.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - cracking post that fancy..quality mate cheers..

20 Jan 2015 22:37:55
Fancy Smith: top post that, mate.

Agree0 Disagree0

Great post that, agree 100%!

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jan 2015 06:47:19
Well said FS, great post. It is imperative that Bill, and the rest of the board for that matter, put both RM and us supporters out of this misery

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 20:31:53
What the hell has happened to our team? As long as I can remember in my 32 years we have always prided ourselves on Everton's dogs of war fighting spirit, even in our darkest and most nerve shredding days (the 1-1 draw with Coventry in 1998 and our 3-2 win over Wimbledon in 1994) our fantastic spirit showed though to watch the ridiculous arguing last night was embarrassing and the players and Martinez should hang their heads in shame!
Which brings me onto Kevin Mirallas who despite his talent has an ego (and not a good one) that dwarfs it. I am truly sick and fed up of players like him trying to play the big man when they are not as good as they think they are, if we get a £10m+ bid get shut of him if he doesn't want to be a team player or he will sit on his big, fat wages on leave on a free in 18 months time. It's just a shame Steven Naismith isn't quite blessed with the talent of some of our players because his workrate and honesty is a joy to behold and exactly what we need to get out of this sh!t!

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 19:40:38
Some players giving half hearted performances to speed up their exit in the transfer window if not now then in the summer 4 sure.
The mirallases & colemans want champions league football sooner rather than later & they ain't going to get it here unless we win Europa league

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 19:35:48
I'm starting to think things were not so bad after all under Moyes at least we had some fight. Sick of the same rubbish under the spanish waiter I've had enough but feel we are stuck with him till summer at least. Depressed.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 18:58:02
Martinez, 'You don't see many games in the Premiership when the opposition has no shots on target'.
No Roberto and as an Everton supporter for nearly 50 years I can't remember any Everton team at home against such poor opposition having only one which was like a back pass to their goalie in the first half.

But at least we now know why Besic was brought off, he was injured! Yer right.

Leighton saying 'we need a break', not as much as the poor bst**ds who pay your wages son.

Just waiting for Bill Kenwright to come on radio in tears over Deidre (which is sad) and not the mess he has single handedly created at our great club.

Nil Satis.? Then act Kenwright

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 19:52:03
Bit harsh on BK Mushy, you remember the Johnston years as well as me mate!
I think RM has pulled the wool over a lot of peoples eyes, especially overachieving like we did last year. Unfortunately, finishing with a record point haul has probably bought him more time than he should be afforded. I think we should judge him on the season Wigan got relegated as we can make comparisons. Did he stick to his guns and his 'philosophy' the season they dropped? Damn right he did. Has he shown he is going to change our style and system? Has he shite. The next few months are going to be as bad as it gets for us fans I feel

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - thats my worry as well spud..

20 Jan 2015 18:32:02
would be nice to get a reply, does anyone know where, osman, pienaar, gibson have gone, and I know we will stay up this season just so nerve wrecking!

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - all injured T94, ..dont bank on us being safe though mate..

20 Jan 2015 22:17:09
Gibbo been injured since day one imo. Reckon Fergie knew he was a dud and that's the reason he went for so little. Pienaar i'm expecting to have come pack and slot himself right next to baines and have that chemistry back, but he's been average for a while. and I reckon Ossie is done also, which is a shame, but perhaps one of the youth can pop up and have a go.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 18:23:13
The silence coming from BK is deafening surely its time to get his head out of his shit shows and be a bloody chairman for once just do the right thing and sack him please. Never thought I'd say this but I'd rather have the wally with the brolly.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - instead we got the fraud who has us bored..

20 Jan 2015 17:19:49
I would like to know what Graeme Jones roll at the club is, as assistant manager does he not have a say in what's going on, Is he advising RM or does RM take no notice of any what advice people around him may offer, Surely GJ must see things are'nt right at the club he must have some input, also I'm sure a lot of us would have liked to hear an apology for that fiasco by KM he's made himself, the manager and club a laughing stock. Last nights display was a disgrace there has to be changes made whether it be players or manager.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - fair comments there kirbo...and as you say an apology to maybe try and build a few bridges would be nice, but im not holding my breath mate..

Screw the apology he's shown his true colours

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 17:17:31
On that performance I don't think Jagielka, Baines and Barkley will be in England's next team. Stones will definitely play. He is also a definite future club captain if he stays. He may be young but why not start next season with him as captain.
When you consider the majority of Evertons team last night were current or past internationals it makes the performance even more pathetic.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

What we have to remember, is that this is the same bunch of players that performed so well last season. With the addition of McGeady. I am sure that although each player is one year older, they have not all suddenly become past it. There must be another explanation. The only explanations that I can com up with are: Team spirit is less. Tactically something is wrong. All the other clubs are much better. Some other factor that I have not thought of is the difference. Out of all these possible reasons, my heart tells me it must be tactics. Last night RM said we were really good first half when we controlled the game and restricted WBA to very few opportunities. He added that second half we were a bit more "gun ho" and this is expected when you are chasing a game and it gives the other team more opportunities. My own assessment is completely the opposite. I thought we were too cautious and created very few opportunities first half ourselves. I though the middle part of the second half was much more exciting and controlled the game more and looked more likely to get a goal. I therefore blame RM's tactics and idea of how to win games. Hence we have drawn so many.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 19:15:02
On current form, them three shouldn't even be playing for our first team! But RH likes defensive minded players (note his choice for world player) so at least two will be safe. Although I think that Stones will be a club captain, whether at EFC or with someone else, it is a little bit early in his career. He still has a lot to learn with regards to the position he plays in, I'd rather he mastered that first. Exciting to think how good he is now and how good he will be in the future. Providing we can keep hold of him.
Degsy, I don't think we were too cautious in the first 45 last night. We were patient on the ball, often going back or sideways. The main reason for this, I thought, was the movement from our attacking players was poor, far too rigid. They didn't seem to be in the right positions at the right time, confidence is lacking throughout. But with you on the tactics shout mate. RM is doing himself no favours at all. The best managers can mix it up depending on who they are playing. They don't stick to plan A every game and hope for the best like our manager. A defeat against Palace should see BK pull the trigger but, IMO, that is too late. We need action now before it gets any worse. The squad team spirit is obviously fractured which is not something we are used to at Goodison. Even with less talented players in recent history, the togetherness has pulled us through at times. This is sadly missing.

Agree0 Disagree0

Agree with what you say Degsy, although one thought has come to mind to add to the mix. Do you remember back in 94 when Big Joe was appointed? One of the first thing he had to do was bring in fitness coaches as the players were so unfit.

We had a shambles of a preseason, and as you say basically the same squad as last year has not become past it within a few months. With extra European games and not being as fit to start with maybe has a part to play?

Agree0 Disagree0

I have to say in my humble opinion, we are dead certs for the drop. We won 5 games earlier on.2 of which we were lucky to. Since then we have been terrible until the last 3. In the last 3 we have been average. Its always 60 odd% possession with no penetration. Almost like a training session. I preferred the football under Moyes.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - if you believe we are certs degs...go to a bookies mate you will make a fortune..

No way could I bring myself to bet against us like that Ed. Likewise, as much as it hurts, I would still be supporting in the Conference.never mind the Championship.

Agree0 Disagree0

I forgot to say why. as explained in my other posts below, I firmly believe the reason for our poor performances lies with tactics. RM has stated that we will not change the tactics. Enough said.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 15:17:15
Ed, do you know when the team is going to Qatar for training, and will there be an opportunity for fans to meet them? I may pop in to see the folks if that's the case.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - they go tomorrow mate..

20 Jan 2015 17:04:00
Oh brilliant. Guess I'll catch them next time haha. Cheers Ed. Was going to give Kev an Ear Rollicking. Reckon my dad will do it for me I suppose.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - tell him to give him a belt from me mate..

20 Jan 2015 18:13:58
Lol will do haha cheers.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 15:56:38
Anyone else notice how pissed Besic was coming off! Only highlights the boys passion and desire to win, the one thing we needed, what a disgraceful substitution it was!

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Yeah, from where I was sitting just for a second it looked like he was going to nut el Bob. Agree the substitution was a disgrace but like you say the lads passion is a credit to him.

Agree0 Disagree0

If you go back to when bk interviewed rm for the job.he asked him how he beat city in the cup final.rm ripped a fag packet open and put his tactics on the back of it. I still think he can put all his tactics on one fag packet. he's got to go.

Agree0 Disagree0

Bet it was a pack of 10!

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 17:05:27
According to Kirkdale (i think), Besic was injured and had a bandage on his foot when he collected his MOTM award. And that's the reason he went off.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - i have heard he was injured as well QB..

Well if he was injured and reacted that way to coming off, we need to buy more Besic's because he obviously has the heart for the fight!

Agree0 Disagree0

He was injured. Bruised foot

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 15:49:38
The main issue I have with last nights performance in an overall summary is that stats say we had 69% possession yet actually never forced their keeper into one meaningful save, so in reality it was 69% of nothing. RM needs to rethink his strategies as they just aren't working! west brom made defending look easy last night as we were clueless in how to break them down. No player really had any inventiveness in their game, it just cried out for one moment of creation, and at the end we lamented a missed penalty!
only two players came out with any credit Besic and Stones and he substituted one, even the media today are turning on their darling Roberto, he won't be sacked and he won't quit so god help us for the rest of the season!

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Same stats could be applied to most games we have played this season with one or two exceptions. Same conclusion too.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 15:13:53
palace (a), lpool (h), chelsea (a), leicester (h), arsenal (a), stoke (a), that's our next 6 games I honestly think we will get 4 points from those game, 1 away to palace and 3 at home to leicester, what do you think?

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 15:09:18
How much do you all rate Barkley av heard a few everton fans slaggin him off lately

Believable0 Unbelievable0

To get that point we'll have to play like WBA did last night!

Agree0 Disagree0

I would take 15mil for him, he cannot pass a ball forward, and keeps loosing the ball.

Agree0 Disagree0

That depends, do you want to buy him? In which case "He is a phenomenal talent, a cross between Michel Ballack and Gazza, best young player to come of of England in 30 years." and all yours for £55 million.

If you just want an opinion, a talented lad with potential but needs a bit of a break from the team for a few games.

Agree0 Disagree0

He's dropped in value more than a Skoda, we were looking at £40m last week!

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - yeah but skoda,s are very reliable wakka..

HAHA nice one Ed025

Agree0 Disagree0

He turned into rodwell last night. Every pass was the easy option and he didn't try anything adventurous at all, he was diabolical

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jan 2015 09:14:51
cut the lad some slack jeez, he's 21 been in and out through injury . asked to play dm . left wing right wing, att mid .

i seen him make his debut in the loss to qpr at goodison at 17 and had the chance of speaking to him in one of the suites , he was the best player on the park by a mile at 17 . he's now 21 , moyes didn't play him enough he's had a few injuries , but he's still a young lad and am sure he's going to be a great player

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 15:02:11
Hey first time back, ed and everyone judeging by speculation, if we sell mirallas what will his valuation be for you I just can't put my finger on his price i'm going with 20mill thanks

Believable0 Unbelievable0

We'll be hard pushed imho to get £10M plus for him given his injury record (hamstring and ankle), his attitude (the penalty), and his length of remaining contract (end of next season) AND especially if we want to get rid (which doesn't seem to be the case, although many fans now think we should) to a Champions League club (domestic or foreign) who will no doubt play hard ball over the transfer fee.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - i think he is the type who would be willing to sit on the bench until his contract expires myself sid..

20 Jan 2015 14:27:11
I don't know what the clubs financial status is regarding bank loans, but if there are outstanding loans then Bill needs to make a quick decision before it's too late. If the bank or banks see the club heading to the championship then they have to look after their interest. If Everton cannot repay debt now in the premiership then they certainly won't be able to do it in the championship. So the banks will act beforehand. It's a long time since Leeds United went down, and still down.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 13:56:45
Have to question Roberto's decision last night. Why play Naisy wide right when he is a natural No. 10 and Dross is clearly not motivated (pulling out of tackles e.t.c)?
Why take off Besic and leave Dross on?
Why when Kone come on was he having to come deep all the time?

I am a massive Mirallas fan and don't agree with what he did. if he isn't playing for the team then he should go.

Thought Besic & Stones were awesome, and loads of enthusiasm & effort from Oviedo.

Onwards & Upwards(hopefully)

Believable0 Unbelievable0

In fairness I thought Barry was one of the better players last night. Only Barry, besic and stones looked half decent the rest of them were a bunch of muppets. It was so bad I'm still beyond livid

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 13:29:49
My thoughts on last night. Miralas was glory hunting because he wants a move this window, it, s priority we get shut.The penalty miss in theory changed the dynamics of the game a goal then would have forced WB to come out and try to score leaving more space for Everton to attack. But you get the feeling that Pullis would have changed tactics and outmanover RM. I supported RM as he looked like he could take us to the next level but clearly he hasn't got it. His tactics and substitutions this season prove this. The team seem to be loosing heart and a change of manager rather than players is urgently needed

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - no arguments from me mate..

Thgfest: I agree.

Agree0 Disagree0

The pundits always mention that the players on the pitch should take their fair share of the blame when things go wrong

Yep, and that's fine, however RM is not a pragmatist, he's not flexible and worst of all he looks like he's fresh out of ideas (lets forget the smiling facade it's pure bravado)

I am like a lot of Evertonians on here I've been around a long time and when I see players who are not happy with their gaffa I recognize it for what it is!

Roberto needs to go sooner rather than later for the sake of our beloved club .

Agree0 Disagree0

I agree, although as much as I personally would like to see a change of manager, however, I don't think it is going to happen for various reasons.

And that is the big concern. Without a change I don't see the results/performances changing. el Bob is not a stupid man, arrogant, stubborn, annoying yes, stupid no. So he must know even if we make it to the end of the season safe his job will be on the line in the summer? My worry is that this will feed his stubborn streak so he can "Prove his philosophy is right." With the result being the same old garbage week in week out till the end of the season.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 13:12:35
is it just me or do we all think we are in deep trouble?

out of form
manager clueless
dressing room trouble
old squad

he either needs to leave or be sacked or show some bloody balls . change his tactics, drop the big names who aren't performing. every evertonian including me must feel some kind of heartbreak watching what's happening to us. time for something to give now ad like to see

joel
browning jags stones garbutt
mirallas barkley besic baines
lukaku naismith

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i agree that our full backs have been poor dazza, but throwing the young guys to the lions would be a massive gamble, i dont want mirallas or barkley in there either, im afraid ross is just not up to the task, and while kev is possibly our best player his attitude stinks mate..

21 Jan 2015 09:20:35
i agree ed but at the moment with injuries we have no1 better . a really think we are in deep water now no win since qpr at home while back is shocking and relegation fodder

not to mention our squad probably being the oldest

osman
howard
pienaar
alcaraz
hibbert
jags
distin
gareth barry
sam eto

there too old in football terms , how are we going to replace them? jags maybe couple years left but he looks a shadow of his former self , was my fav player , but he's been awful

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - when you actually see it down on paper dazza you can see how old the squad really is mate, frightening really..

21 Jan 2015 09:47:25
exactly ed I've been saying it on here for ages with people moaning about us, and its there for us all to see our squard is too old and not good enough

ontop of that we have sick notes in mirallas and gibson who can't stay fit kone whos 31 and always injured . there's 13 players ed. 11 are 31 + 2 are sick notes

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - your not making me feel any better about the situation dazza!.. :)

21 Jan 2015 13:19:56
sorry ed , but there's a lot of people on here who are wearing blue tinted glasses. unless kenwright has the balls to eitehr sack rm or tell him he has to turn it around and quick were in trouble , if we don't sign anyone in jan - I fear the worst

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 13:12:34
I was undecided when RM was appointed Manager. for same reasons as most. wigans style of football and relegation. However, the events of last year saw me swept along and increased the expectation for this year. However, just like the everton team all my confidence in everton and the manager has slowly but surely trickled away. The problem is clearly RMs uncompromising approach, tactical niaivity . infuriating. Firstly the tactic of playing your favoured 11 players rather than your strongest 11 man team isnot correct. if certain players need a rest or are under performing (Barry, Ross, McGeady and IMO coleman) then you should be rested. Last night Berkley had been switched from wing (where he does not belong) to centre and naismith to rightwing. the same position DM played him in resulting in him being slated. Naismiths role for me is either along side or just behind Romelu. For me Berkley needed to be rested and Naismith pick up a central role where he has been great this season. you don't move him to acommodate a player who is out of form?? Secondly for months now Romelu has looked isolated. From the off Rom was surrounded by a triangle of two CBs behind him and a CM infront of him. everton were not being bossed in midfield and clearly the team was crying out for 4 4 2 which ould have changed WBAs tactics and limted the marshalling of Rom - after 15 minutes this was clear. RM addressed this after 79 minutes? Finally although probably the best performance came from Besic someone has to tell the guy when running toward the opposition half/goal, with an opposition player behind you, DO NOT suddenly turn towards your own goal into that opposing player. Finally offside from a short corner, consitently failing to clear front post when crossing a ball and continuously trying to tip-tap your way into the opposing box clearly demonstrates that RMs current and only way of playing is not good enough. Its time for him to prove how capable he really is.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - good post that mate..and very fair..

20 Jan 2015 12:17:44
Sly Sports Interviewer;
"Roberto, when do you see the teams current run of bad form turning around?"

Roberto:
"This is a current run where we find ourselves enjoying our football and is reeellee pleasing to bee fullee committed and see the character of the cloob shining throo."

Sly sports Int;
"Yes but you are perilously close to the drop zone and are increasingly being sucked down into a relegation dogfight that, with all due respect I don`t think either you or the players have the stomach for."

Roberto: "Yes we are meeeteeng these challenges with a smile and enjoying our football, playing with smiles on our faces as we enjoy our football and playing weeth a smile on our faeces as we enjoy our football."

Sly sports Int;" Roberto what happens if you are relegated?"

Roberto: " We weel be presented with a fantastic opportuneety to return to the preemieership as soon as wee can and we weell play our football weeth a smile on our faeces."

Sly sports Int:
"Roberto do you understand the proud history and heritage associated with this football club? What it means to this great city and what this great club means to the supporters from all over the world, do you understand the responsibility you have as steward of the club, the expectations, the desire, the passion of those fans, do you understand the fans commit for life and so journey through their lives suffering and celebrating everything this great institution succeeds at or fails with, Everyday life is affected by this Everton, We live and breathe BLUE, are you aware of ALL of this? Do you understand? Roberto?"

Roberto; "Que?"

ssn Int; "Excuse me?"

Roberto;

"Pleesee Mr. Fawlty. HHHMMMM, . Hhhmmmm, sorry about that what was your question again? Oh! em Yes. We weel be enjoying theees fantastic opportunity to bee very focused and work hard to smile weeth our faeces and play weeth ourselves"

Sly sports Int; "Roberto, you`re talking B_llox "

Roberto; "Thank you"

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i enjoyed that hugster..

Hugsterefc: Good funny read that! I like RM being Manuel to BK being Basil Fawlty. I wonder which other characters in that show would equate to certain posters on this site?

Agree0 Disagree0

That raised a smile right around the workshop on an otherwise morbid day. Top post mate!

Agree0 Disagree0

Sibil Faulty at Goodison last night. The person next to her said "who is that man over there on the touch line chewing gum, screwing his face and
throwing his arms about".
Sibil says " That's Roberto, he's from Barcelona".

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 20:52:35
I'd have BK as the major; terribly nice chap but living in his own little world from 30 years ago and totally out of touch with the real world.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 10:57:06
1 win in 13 is relegation form. Lighting the candle's as we speak. R.I.P Evertons Premier League Status.

Line up for next season.

Joel
Browning Distin Alcaraz Oviedo
Barry Lundstrum
Mcgeady Naismith Pienaar
Kone.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

I reckon some of that XI wouldn't be sticking around either. If we go down - and don't get back up while the parachute payments are coming in - then I reckon the subsequent lack of finance will make us become a side of promising youngsters (who'll regularly be sold to keep the club afloat) and cheap lower-tier journeymen (past their sell-by date and/or poor quality). Then we'll be languishing in the lower tiers and be praying for a cup giant-killing or a run at the promotion playoffs to lighten the inevitable long stretch of mediocrity and failure.
RM left Wigan in part because he didn't feel he was the manager to get them back. If we go down - and he isn't already removed by BK - then will he quit for the same reason?
In HK's third spell, he said he wasn't getting his beloved Everton relegated on his watch - and we escaped by the skin of our teeth. Can BK and RM be sure it won't happen on their watch?
As for the players, do they just collect their big wages, shrug their shoulders, blame the management, coaches, referees, bad luck, the phases of the moon, etc., etc., OR are they as deeply concerned as the fans are? Where are the Tim Cahill or Micky Lyons or other players who were devoted to the Everton cause and were leaders?
I despair for our club :-(

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 10:56:31
Evertonians pride themselves on knowledge of their club and of football by singing "If you know your history".
Well, if anyone knows their English history, they'll know what Oliver Cromwell said to an ineffectual parliament: "You have sat too long for any good you have been doing lately. Depart I say and let's have done with you. In the name of God, go!"
I was one of those fans who was very pleased with the appointment of RM - and was hugely encouraged by last season - but now I see no belief in the fans let alone the players. If we get into a last-day must-win scenario (like in the 1990s), then I don't see RM or these players having it in them to survive.
So, with a heavy heart - and with my joints aching from all of the recent knee-jerk reactions - I implore BK to replace RM and save our football club and ensure the continuation of our club's sixty seasons of top-tier football. We've only ever spent four seasons outside the top tier: that's a proud record that we are now putting at serious risk with the current situation.
There'll be plenty of time at the end of the season to reflect on what actually happens, but for now just hoping for the best and thinking that we're too good to go down isn't going to cut it in the ruthless and realistic world of competitive Premier League football.
Act now!

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i cant see that happening sid, as much as i admire bill hes not the sort of character to fire a manager at this stage, by the way, all this happening to us is a joy for the media, they are loving every minute of it!..

I have spoken about misplaced loyalty before and like most I admire Bill for getting us away from Johnson. However, I thought it was a knee jerk reaction to appoint Roberto and do not feel proud in being vindicated. Last season we played more direct passing football but honestly believe that Roberto's thinking had not really sunk into the Squad. His style and philosophy is just not suited to the intensity of the Premiership resulting in Everton playing scared. Over the next couple of days Bill really has to examine his conscience and do what is best and that is tell Roberto to go because I tell you retaining him will result in us going down.

Agree0 Disagree0

I have always had reservations about RM as Ed025 will testify

Last season I almost conformed to the opinion that he was the right man for the job etc.

This season however he has looked like the guy I identified in the first place

This league doesn't lie, there is no reading between the lines at all

It says quite clearly ' in view of the quality of Evertons squad Roberto Martinez has seriously got it wrong'

I wholeheartedly agree! :(

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - so do i mate..

20 Jan 2015 10:47:18
This is starting to get out of hand now, I'm still Behind the manager, alls I think he needs is a fit McCarthy and another proper out and out winger, there's no point playing 4-2-3-1 if kev is effectively playing as the left and right winger because no one else has the pace/quality to play there well (Oviedo gives his best like but I don't think he's the answer) one final thing someone needs to tell Ross to shoot/ attack etc. Why he wants to sit back and play the holding role I don't know. Any ideas? Do need a new winger pace, power and hopefully a eye for goal. Peresic would be ideal like

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - we do need width jay, but mcgeady is not the answer mate..

20 Jan 2015 10:14:05
Hi Fellow Blues
Never posted before but have been visiting the site for a couple of years now.
This post is now really out of pure frustration. But for me Mirallas must now go and take Samuel with him. Not disputing the quality or talent, but his petulance, non defending and overall attitude are abysmal. He is not a team player and will never be. I can't say I know what is going on internally but judging from last night he might not be the best to have around currently. Maybe that is why Aiden gets picked ahead of him. Just my view, and my apologies for the above but I needed to get it out.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i agree SA..

Thank you Ed025. can't believe I'm saying this but can't wait for Osman, Mac and Pienaar. Ross and Barry need to be benched.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - ossie will at least give us a bit of craft and guile SA, and macca will give us some energy, pienaar needs to buck his ideas up for him to make a difference as well, but ross does need to be taken out of the firing line for his own good mate..

SAToffee: until this season, I wasn't impressed by KM's effort. This season, he started playing like he meant it - maybe he was playing for a transfer!
However, the penalty fiasco was beyond the pale. I say get rid of him now before his valualation lowers.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - count me in on that sid...big head no bread in the house..

Reports say he is 7/2 to go to spurs aron lennon an 5 million would do for me

Agree0 Disagree0

Km is quality, that we need imo, don't need his attitude though if it were spurs he goes to, i'd be asking for dembele and lennon straight swap

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - christian eriksen or the money for me dazza..

If KM wants CL football - which clearly isn't on the cards at Everton next season (!) - then why would he go to Tottenham? Other than Arsenal, I don't see the likes of next season's likely other English CL qualifiers (Chelsea, ManCity, ManUtd) being interested in KM. More likely some CL club in Europe (Dortmund?) would be his destination. We just need to get top dollar for him before his contract runs down.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - the dosh would be very welcome sid...but more importantly for me would be a statement from the club that he will be shown the door for being an absolute prat that wont be tolerated by this club, as a warning to any other prima donnas who think they are bigger than everton fc..

Ed025: your wished-for reaction of the club to KM would be welcome and a breath of fresh air - which is why I'd be pleasantly (and amazedly!) surprised if it actually happened. I suspect that the more critical the fans become, the more entrenched that RM will become in sticking to his "principles" and the more BK will stick to his "don't panic and stick by his choice of RM" attitude and the more the club will meekly and cravenly forgive the indiscretions and failures of the players no matter what they're costing us.
:-(

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 09:47:45
Had a night of restless sleep to mull over what happened last night. Two positives from the game, Besic looks a great signing and we managed to keep a clean sheet (not that it was very difficult against a team that didn't want to attack.

I probably know about as much about football as the rest of my fellow evertonians (which is a lot by the way ;). I have never managed a club nor played football at any higher a standard as local Saturday league.

So what does Martinez and the players discuss/train for over the course of the week in preparation of playing West Brom, who as we know are managed by Tony Pulis who if nothing else organises a team not to concede.

For starters were two holding midfielders necessary against a team that will stay in their own half for 70% of the match? absolutely not! Yet it took RM till 79th minute when he brought on Kone to realise this. Which again was the wrong sub to bring on. We lacked two things last night, width and creativity in the middle. Bringing on Kone is fine if you have someone who will cross the ball to him. Granted the choices on the bench were a bit limited, but I would have brought on Hibbo and moved Seamus to right wing. I don't think there was anything else we could have done in those circumstances.

The Mirallas penalty incident, screamed out to me a lack of leadership on the pitch. Jagielka should have stepped in and given the ball to Baines. I am not going to turn on Mirallas over this, it was very naive of him and shouldn't have happened, but he has been one of the very few bright sparks this season, and we are going to need him to help us try and survive.

Barkley, had we anyone else available who could play central midfield would have been dropped after the West Ham match. He was so bad that night, however I think he managed to top that with one of the worst performances I have ever seen. A lot of pressure as been piled on this lad, with talks of big money transfers and being compared to Gazza and Rooney and who ever else the media can think of. He has a natural flair and talent which on a good day you see 30% of the game. Its the other 70% of these games that I question his confidence, attitude, his desire and overall his fitness. A lad of his age and ability should have run the show last night. However all he did everytime he walked onto the ball was pass backwards or sideways. Only made one run, near the end, and would not shoot (trying to copy Barry). Going back to the QPR game I thought he was fantastic, spraying the ball around, tackling, dribbling and a superb goal, but this all coincided from playing in a deeper position. Something is not quite right there and Martinez I think is ruining his career.

Defensively we have looked better in the last few games and to be fair Robles has looked a good keeper now he has had a run of games.

I think we will struggle this season but based on other teams in the league I don't think we will go down.

Bill isn't going to get rid of Martinez half way through the season we all know that is never going to happen.

So assuming we stay up, come the summer the board need to either back this person or bring a new face in. The former would be my guess.

We then have to look at the squad which is worryingly old. Pienaar, Osman, Distin, Kone, Alcaraz, Jags, Baines, Howard, Barry, Gibson, Hibbo are all the wrong side of 30. Of those Distin, Alcaraz, Pienaar, Kone, Barry, Gibson and Hibbo shoud be shown the door. Which leaves us a lot of players to bring in. Browning and Garbutt look good enough to back up Baines and Seamus. The rest we will need to find money, which we will envitably not have much of.

Looking forward to a weekend where I can watch some FA Cup football without having the stress of watching our lot.

Bring on Palace.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - bring on the vallium..

20 Jan 2015 09:24:53
One less game to go in the league and we are still 5 to 6 wins from safety. We have only beaten wba away burnley away villa home qpr home and a west ham team with 4 to 5 players injured at home. Our run of fixtures now is tough. The game last night; Mirralas shouldn't have taken the penalty, we are lucky enough to have a reliable penalty taker in baines let him take it. Jags should have taken the ball off him and gave it to baines and put him in his place. If Kev was carrying a knock it is even worse. I think barkley needs to be taken out of the team for a few games for his sake, whether he stays at everton or goes he needs to be out of the team. I feel a bit sorry for the lad in one way the crowd were really turning on him last night and as a blue he wants to do well. however he doesn't help himself pulling out of tackles and giving ball away, maybe all the hype around him has proved too much. In the style of roberto martinez let's look at the positives, Stones had a good game and at one point was driving us forward down the right wing, class act that lad. We kept a clean sheet however you will not see many teams with as little endeavour as that come to goodison. Very worried now relegation or at least the battle is looming with two many players who haven't got a fight in them. A manager who appears to have lost the dressing room and has lost a signifucant part of the crowd. It is obvious no changes will be made before the end of the season so I think we are down to a hope and a prayer.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i agree with that sean, jags for me is too nice a guy to be captain, he is very weak for me, and that is not a knee jerk as i said so before the game last night, ross is such an enigma, he has bags of talent but always flatters to decieve, and taking him out of the spotlight would do him a favor imo, i do believe that bobby has lost the dressing room as well which is not good, and now is the time for the players to stand up and be counted, we have the ability and players to get us out of this mess though so not all is lost mate..

The ability is there ed that's the frustrating thing. I said to my mate last night this would be the best group of individuals to be relegated from the premiere league ever. But not the best team because they do not like a team at the minute. Arguing over penalties, lots of pointing on the pitch it is so disjointed.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - tell me about it sean..

Agree with ed on jags not being captain material. The only stand out contenders for me would be naisy, Jimmy mac or maybe Coleman.players who can be vocal on pitch and give others a rollicking

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 09:16:27
Well Martinez must be laughing his sock off now.
Previous games it's been the ref he could blame for missing this, that and the other. But on a night when the whole world could see what crap we're playing he gets the Mirrales v Baines fiasco to hide behind.
Most, if not all, Evertonians can now see the dire situation we are in. Last night the media should have been asking why the fluk was Besic taken off? Why was Barkley left on? But no. a stupid argument, albeit one that probably cost us 2 points, was sent from the heavens for that 'manager' of ours.

I want him out now, before the next match. I really believe the tea lady could do a better job.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i dont think thats going to happen mac, my problem is that i cant see any light at the end of the tunnel, we are so one dimensional and predictable, we have palace next who are on a roll with a new manager and belief, then liverpool who would like nothing better than for them to put us in the relegation mire, these are testing times to be an evertonian mate..

Shades of Beckford methinks and I have thought this before about Mirallas!

He should find a club that thrives on big headed losers :(
Btw good luck with that one mate.

RM once again won the PL weekend awards for 'Stubborn #$@&%!'

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 08:46:19
What about approaching Sczezney for a loan deal. Not a bad risk and as a goal keeper he can smoke his lungs out if he wants.

On a more serious note, let's get behind the lads. Sure mistakes have been made, but I am sure of 1 thing, positive energy from the crowd is a big factor for morale and filters through to better performances.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i dont think the supporters can share any blame in this smeggs, they pay good money to go home and away to watch that dross, yet always get behind the team, its hard sometimes when you know we can be so much better, pass pass pass can be so frustrating, ross must have touched the ball about 100 times last night, yet never one of them meant anything..im not saying dont be vocal in your support mate, just that it can be very hard at times..

I said before the game the crowd would be edgy in truth it was dead. Best atmosphere was at half time. The problem is they do nothing exciting enough to get the crowd going. There were parts of that game were I was genuinely bored and down right depressed with what was being played.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - thats what i was saying to sa90 sean, its easy to say support and be vocal and enthusiastic, but when we see predictable boring ineffective play like last night its really hard mate..

Sure you are right Ed. It is hard to keep smiling under such circumstances. Controlling negativity is bloody difficult. All I am saying is the team needs us in hard times.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - i agree with that smeggs mate, but you have to realize that its just as hard for us supporters..

Ed I understand what you are syaing but unfortunately its human nature to lose confidence when you are being slagged off. don't get m wrong I am not happy at all with the way we are playing but we will not do ourselves any favours by being negative towards the team on match day. just as an aside not I thought last nights performance was not dissimilar to some of our performances under DM. We controlled that game completely but just could not get a goal.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - we never looked like scoring mate..

20 Jan 2015 08:37:39
Message for Roberto

Stop the smiling, it's not bleeding funny

Sorry Ed, bit peeved off like the rest of us

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i understand your frustration murf..but obviously had to change a few words mate..

20 Jan 2015 11:53:55
ha ha, cheers ed, it sounds a bit more respectable now

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - i would have liked the original murf..but theres rules mate.. :)

20 Jan 2015 06:44:15
I started following Everton after watching them lose to Liverpool in the FA Cup in 1986. All the muppets here wanted to follow Liverpool because of Craig Johnson but I went and followed Everton. I was 13 so I ain't born and Bred. I have only seen Everton when they toured Australia and I went around the country watching all there games. I have booked a trip next year to England to watch Everton play. So I am pleading with the supporters there, Swan, Degsypulford, Cowpat Sid or Jonesy we need to start a demonstration, rally whatever you want to call it demanding Martinez Out. The people need to be heard. This man is killing this great club and if he continues to the end of the year we will be relegated. Its getting to the point where things are getting scary. I remember listening on BBC radio when Everton were to 2 nil down to Wimbledon and I was crying. I don't want that feeling ever again but I can't see things improving. I feel like coming over to the UK (even though I can't afford it yet) and try and save my club that I love only second to my wife and Kids and starting a campaign to get rid of Martinez. Please someone do something.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Aussie, I hear what you say. But I want to just explain some fundamental things about running a football club.no matter what the level. I have posted many times on here about people saying, "this player. or that player is crap. Get rid of them!" This sounds like the logical thing to do. I have upset quite a few people on here this season by suggesting they know nothing about running a club because before you get rid of someone, you must have someone else who you consider better to take over. That goes from the Chairman to the tea lady. Right now, we have no one lined up to take over from RM. Nor Bill Kenwright. We must stick with both for 2 reasons. 1. we will not find a replacement straight away. 2. we are at a critical stage of the season and to have a "rudderless" ship so as to speak would be a disaster. We must plan ahead. We must also give our support to the players who go out every week training and playing and giving their all. I believe (and have always believed) that RM inherited a good squad. I also believe he made a great signing in Lukaku. I also believe he has the players scared to break from defence quickly. The 2 full backs in particular seem reluctant to get to the bye line and whip crosses in like they used to. That does not make us a bad team overnight. Some of RM's signings have been questionable. Selling Anichebe and replacing with Kone. Atsu, McGeady, Barry, McCarthy, will score no more than 2 goals per season between them. I got shouted down by some of my fellow supporters for suggesting this, but fact is I am correct. I also pointed out that Baines and Coleman are suffering from a lack of Osman and Pienaar. I was again shouted down in certain quarters. Hopefully these two will return and we will also start breaking out quicker and getting those whipped crosses in. Right now we need to remain calm and pull together.get behind the players. and yes. RM too. Otherwise we will really fall apart and see the Championship quicker than the back of Mirallas!

Agree0 Disagree0

Degsy, spot on except for the part about Ossie and Seamus down the right IMO the best partnership is Kev and Seamus, I always thought Ossie played better in the middle of the park.

Agree0 Disagree0

We can't stick with Martinez degsy. Players don't have the freedom and the game plan looks shot. We are being exposed all over the park. Then he never subs Barry. Always someone else. We will be relegated if Martinez is not sacked. Who can we get. I don't know. Maybe Sir Alex Ferguson till the end of the season (that's out of left field). Don't worry about a payout. Cause when we get relegated we will lose a lot more money. Sponsors will jump off! TV money gone. He has to go and he has to go now.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 06:05:09
So many fickle fans! Mirallas has to go because he missed a pen? I understand he may not want to be here at the moment, but I'm sure many other players feel the same way, and that may be the reason you want him to leave. However Mirallas is one of our best players, and possibly the only with any flair (that is actually useful). If he had scored that Penalty it would be all 'Super Kev' this and 'Super Kev' that, on here. Also, now Robles is world class? He has been decent recently, but many were saying he is utter trash and should leave, just three weeks ago! And now he should be first XI even when Howard returns? People are saying 'We don't need to sign a keeper now, we can just stick with Robles' What the heck? This isn't directed at everyone, but some people need to get a grip and stop saying after a good match players are brilliant for a good performance, and then after a poor one saying they should leave! If Robles has another poor match I guarantee there will be tens of posts about how awful he is and how he should never wear an everton shirt again. It is just pathetic! If you give an opinion on a player stick by it, if they keep showing their flaws then fair enough, just don't change your mind and cry about a player for one game.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

It is not just the fact that he missed the penalty (I agree he should stay and try his damnedest) but rather the manner of his taking it. By the reaction of the players on the pitch, even his own Country Man it showed he was going against Team instructions and also showed the lack of discipline and mistrust in the Squad. Roberto has gone from hero to zero by in the space of 18 months turning us into Wigan, Quite a feat.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 07:10:32
Fickle? Did you see how many turned up last night? Do you go to the away games where we always turn up on mass? It's not fickle mate, it's the fact that we are watching dross, and as fans we are entitled to view are frustrations. We had a poor finish to last season, a poor pre season, and have been dire this season. Fickle, Jesus I think we all deserve an MBE for services to our club.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2015 02:13:38
Did the team just set the all time PL record for the product of time of possession multiplied by completed passes? It is a shame that we can't be awarded a goal for fabulous repetitive passing.

To borrow a phrase from golf, at least 99% of the balls that don't make it to the hole never go in.

Uggh. at least Besic and Stones looked solid. Unsure-Kev's PK was awful.

Can we get Big Vic back. He can stand his ground with an army climbing on his back, and his feet are are less the cement blocks that Rom wears.

Also. perhaps we need to figure how Southampton sold off players and ended up in the top 5.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 00:29:40
RM might well become a successful head coach at a club like Barcelona, who can afford the best players that have the tecnical skills to play how he wants, and play in a league that's nowhere near as physically demanding or competitive as the Premier League where, by and large, even a lesser team can, on its day, defeat a higher-placed team.
But until then, it's no use imho experimenting with tactics and formations that make our available players look like square pegs in round holes. For all the criticism of DM's lack of ambition or positivity, he did (for the most part) at least follow the Clint Eastwood (Dirty Harry) approach: a man's got to know his limitations. Of late - whether due to pressure from the players or whatever - we have mixed up our passing and possesion play with a little directness. However, it's results that count and were not winning - and that is ultimately down to the manager and how he prepares the team.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2015 09:24:39
Sid, IMO you are sport on we are not a team with the skills to play the way RM really wants to play. This has been a hard season as our style of play has been assessed and neutralised by most clubs. The fact that we have started to mix it a little more is promising but we do need wins I don't think draws will keep us safe. let's hop ewe get a bit of luck soon as we have not had much recently.

Agree0 Disagree0

Sa90: I think we had some good luck earlier in the season - we certainly rode our luck in those matches (Europa League for example) where we had good results. Since before Cristmas we've also had luck - two types: bad luck and no luck! Likewise, imho we have two chances of recovering this season: no chance and slim chance - and Slim has left town!

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - lets hope bobby follows him..

20 Jan 2015 00:04:05
RM can be as positive as he likes, and he can praise the players's desire to do better as much as he likes, and he can complain about refereeing decisions as much as he likes, but the only things that count in football are results and accumulating points and that simply means our team scoring goals and our team not conceding goals. Be that - both offensively and defensively - from open play or set pieces doesn't matter: they all count however they're scored.
Once the players cross the white line onto the pitch, it's up to them to perform. However, it's up to RM to prepare the players - mentally, physically, technically, and tactically - and if he can't do that in a way that gets results, then I have to concede that he hasn't turned out to be "the right one, the bright one" and BK should bring RM's tenure to an end.
So sad, but our club must not be allowed to fail :-(

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i agree sid..

20 Jan 2015 00:00:14
Were a laughing stock mate I'm sure sky pundits Carragher & neville were spot on in their assessment over the big talking point whether baines or mirallas took the pen.
No brainer 4 me jags should have sorted it out as team capt & given it to our regular pen taker bainsey.
Would'nt surprise me 1 bit whether mirallas missed deliberately to force his jan move out the door.
Eto on his way looks like mirallas not far behind whose next Coleman, Mcarthy.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - hopefully the manager jonsey..

What a mess even the wife pissed of with rm. first time I have ever heard her swear and trust me living with me for 40 years the saying something. besic subbed f k of rm.the red rubbish will take us apart. going to find a cat to kick

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - if you find one pass it on to me streety..

Aye never subs Barry mate the player that slows the team down similar to Phil Neville in his last couple of seasons absolute joke

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - besic has become the scapegoat jonsey..

 
Change Consent