Everton Banter Archive November 12 2012

12 Nov 2012 22:21:30
How much would Holtby cost in January considering his contract runs out next summer?

ToffeeMike {Ed025's Note - at a guess £6m..

12 Nov 2012 21:33:50
Big Felli has added a new dimension to his game this season, he's now scoring goals for fun! we paid 15 million for him, and since then he's matured and is no longer getting booked every week, he has expanded his game, now he's a DM,CM,AM all with equal quality, he's 24 and has 4 years left on his contract. So by my calculations and going by market value he has to be worth 45-50 million!

Kurajan

12 Nov 2012 21:08:49
Whats going on with Victor Anichebe,anyone?

Nothing, he's always been usless

He is not useless, been good for us this season so stop ripping our players apart.

ToffeeMike

I agree. Vic's no
Messi (if only he was :D) however whenever called upon he has done his job with no moaning. He's just unlucky that he has to battle with Jela.

Anyway, he's been missing for the last few weeks due to injury. He was on the bench for Fulham away, up until 14:55. He was replaced on the bench by Duffy because he had thrown up or something like that. And then he wasn't on the bench this week because he picked up an injury playing for the U21s.

Just to confirm, the poster who said something along the lines of 'Moyes and Anichebe have had a bust up and Anichebe will be sold in January' is absolute tosh.

Keith EFC.

Anichebe was ill, then picked up an injury in the U/21 game.

Cant believe people still slagging him off, the lad is scoring more or less every time he gets on the pitch, what more do you want, looks actually dangerous when he plays now.

12 Nov 2012 18:51:59
Oh here we go, a few weeks from the transfer window and the rumours start.....

Please stop being so negative, Fellani's going nowhere until at least the summer!

Are these the same people that where saying Baines is going???

Show me some "Evidence" to back up your "Theorys" and I might start listening.

Until then..... Piss off and Troll another site.

Gods Doctor

Please note - All comments will be met with a strong opinion and a view to put you down like an old 3 legged dog with rabies!!

What's up Doc ? The media starts these rumours off for a very good reason... They're sensation seeking parasites ! They've put 2 and 2 together and on this occasion got 4 because who wouldn't be interested in taking the big fella ? But he stays if we get CL and goes if we don't. Quite simple really.

Some evidence? for exemple the fact that david moyes himself talked about possibility to sell him?

No namer..... Show me the link to that interview!

Gods Doctor

14 Nov 2012 13:24:54
here: http://www.liverpooldailypost.co.uk/sport/everton-fc/everton-fc-news/2012/11/12/marouane-fellaini-can-lead-everton-into-champions-league-says-david-moyes-99623-32215446/

Why has my other link not be posted? it was from the official everton website... {Ed025's Note - never seen it mate...but the site does frown on references to other web sites, as there are legal issues with some of them..

12 Nov 2012 17:43:13
Ed any news on any possible transfer targets?
Eg holtby nice vadis etc?

Thanks
Eddy {Ed025's Note - sorry eddy, nothing yet mate, perhaps it's a bit early..

12 Nov 2012 13:12:37
Who would have thought at the start of the season we would be sat in fourth after 11 games trying to shake off West Brom and West Ham!

Best League in the world!

Blue Bones

Agreed - apart from the fact that money talks and its all bought and paid for these days - unlike pre 90s where a guy like Clough could take a team like Notts forest and win the European Cup - twice - now fergie n his mates in Europe have stitched it up so its always the same teams at the top - well it was until chelski and Man C gategrashed uninvited - now once the fair play rules come in fergie had got what he wanted again - so same old same old

I'd love it if we finished fourth and broke the mold but teams with more money like chelski and arsenal will come and take our best players if we look like being a real threat
clozem

Take our players, not without handing over wheelbarrows full of Cash. Players of real value, Fellaini 45m, Jelavic 25m Baines 25m Mirallas 30m. Just my opinion but would not sell any of these players for a penny less than the prices I put on them. Thoughts ED and fellow Blues am I way of with my valuations. Barkley?? in a couple of years we will no his valuation too.

Dero ( Irish Blue )

I think you are miles away with these valuations myself- Realistically--Fellaini £30-35m, Jelavic £12-15m, Baines £15-20m, Mirallas £10-15m. Barkley?... who knows, same as Rodwell most likely

12 Nov 2012 11:55:30
If Andy Carroll Is Worth £35 Million! Then Fellaini has got to be worth more than £30 million that's the price getting thrown around? Myself personally would be edging towards the £40 mil mark! What are your thoughts?.....

Does it matter? he will be sold..Everton cannot keep hold of there best players. Maybe our Roman may give you 18 million for him.

Go home and don't insult us with £18M, that wouldn't even buy his right leg, Roman will be fed up soon.

And your Ruski mafioso can whistle. £30m at least or he can take his custom elsewhere.

Says the team that have no history


also no name

paddock toffee

He is good, but I don't think he is worth anywhere near £40 million. Just as Carroll wasn't worth £35 million. I think around £25m is a fair price for Fellaini.

Mike {Ed025's Note - now why does,nt that surprise me?...I'm shocked that you never said less mike!, you really are one miserable sod!

Typical arrogance from the plastic chelski 'fans'. Let's face it without 'your roman' you'd be a mid-table side and you would probably be supporting Man C instead. Glory seeking tarts with no knowledge of football. Worst 'fans' in the country by a clear margin. Disgraceful.

For 18 million our david may give you a no. {Ed025's Note - or maybe a PMSL..

Mike we paid £15m for him as a then 19yr old ? And now, for all-round ability and versatility he has no peers. I agree the donkey isn't worth anywhere near £35m, but the market says otherwise, and if we were to go by that rationale Fellaini is worth £70m as he's twice the player Carroll is. But, realistically, a fair price would be £30-35m IMO.

In my opinion, £25m-£30m would be a fair price for Fellaini, ed. What price would you say? You can't honestly think he is worth close to £40 million, but if you do, then fair enough.

Mike {Ed025's Note - I really believe he can command a fee over £30m mike..

Yeah right, 18 million, maybe we'l put a swap deal in why we're at it, Tony Hibbert for Mata anyone?
Toffeepidge

12 Nov 2012 15:47:30
I'm sorry mike but 25m you're having a laugh, he's arguably the most inform player in the prem and he keeps getting better, he's only 24, and why shouldn't we get 40m if he played for utd that's the price yoy would be looking at, when you look at what other players have gone for, carrols,torres,even 20m for downing, we should be asking top dollar, even palace are asking 20m for zaha, and if you think that's to much, remember I bet every team in the prem would want him in their team right now but saying that I wouldn't sell him in jan, he could be the difference between cl and europa league.
Ste c {Ed025's Note - I agree with all that ste..

I wouldn't sell for £50m! If we're serious about getting 4th, we have to keep hold of him! Plus who could we seriously get as a replacement?? {Ed025's Note - good point mate..

Market forces was the important phrase used by another. If I am right, Felli signed a new 4 year deal a few months back. That means he is tied to us unless he goes on strike or causes unrest as per Lescott. In which case we reluctantly hold out for the highest bidder. Then we only deal if the deal is right for us. Moyes does not give players away. Unless they are past their best. I would guess he would command a fee of 40 million. The fee paid by Reds for Carroll.....compare with the fee paid by United for Robin Van Persil.....24 million. It's all about contracts and like I say Felli signed a 4 year one. We hold the upper hand. Degsypulford

He penned a new 5 year deal last November I believe, degsypulford, so he still has 4 yrs remaining plus he's still just 24 therefore would have a re-sale value. We're talking at least £30m here and probably more. He's the complete player.

12 Nov 2012 11:11:37
I would just like to give credit to Tim Howard he has come in for some criticism lately but he made a couple of good saves Saturday and also came out and taken a cross and commanded his 6 yard box. he should take credit for 3pts also.

Robbie

11 Nov 2012 23:53:12
Sorry ed ... Not really banter but do you know if the club are auctioning off the Poppy shirts from yesterday?

Cheers

BigPhil {Ed025's Note - yes they are Phil, with the proceeds going to the poppy appeal mate..

Ed, Do you have the details of when the auction will be? BlueTone {Ed025's Note - they are being auctioned via the clubs web site tone..

Cheers buddy!